Cake Menu Items

All cake flavors can made into cupcakes


  • Banana
  • Bushwacker: vanilla sponge cake soaked in Coconut Rum, Bailey's Irish Cream, Amaretto & Kahlua, filled with Milk Chocolate Butterceam*
  • Carrot*
  • Chocolate Blackout
  • Cookies & Cream*
  • Coconut
  • Hazelnut*
  • Key Lime
  • Lemon
  • Rum Punch: rum & pink guava cake with a filling of pineapple, pink guava, passion-fruit and coconut cream*
  • Red Velvet
  • Tres Leches: Classic Latin American favorite of spongecake soaked with three milks & dark rum, filled with either fresh mango or raspberries*
  • Vanilla Chiffon
  • Vienna Cake: Caribbean Style; vanilla cake layered with homemade mango, guava & pineapple jams*

    • Bavarian Cream*
    • Caramel Buttercream
    • Chocolate Truffle*
    • Chocolate Mousse*
    • Coconut Cream*
    • Coffee Crème Brûlée*
    • Cream Cheese*
    • Dulce de Leche*
    • Guava Jam
    • Key Lime Curd
    • Lemon Curd
    • Mango Jam*
    • Passion Fruit Curd
    • Pina Colada*
    • Raspberry Compote*
    • White Chocolate Buttercream*


    • Almond
    • Chocolate
    • Chai
    • Hazelnut*
    • Lime
    • Mocha
    • Peanut Butter*
    • Rum
    • Vanilla


    • Chocolate covered strawberries

    *Denotes apremium surcharge.

    Vegan and gluten free options.

    Don’t see a flavor you’d like? Spark our imagination!

    logo of Cake Bakery in Tillett Gardens, St. Thomas, USVI

    CAKE BAKERY St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands

    Tuesday - Friday: 9am-4pm. Saturday: 9am-1pm
    Stay informed with local news and our specials. Follow us on social media @IslandSweetStuff

    View Our Cakes